Pic from this NZ Herald article

by Penny Tucker

RNZ’s problem is not that it has insufficient funding to reach its audience. It is that it has sufficient funding to ignore it. Lord Reith famously envisaged public broadcasting as a means to inform, educate and entertain. RNZ appears to have substituted indoctrinate, admonish and invoice.

Radio New Zealand might consider spending less time holding its ideological foes to account and more time doing its own accounts. Having received $67.3 million in government funding last financial year, exceeded its personnel budget by $3.2 million and its operating budget by $6.4 million, and established an overdraft facility without the requisite ministerial approval, RNZ is fast becoming the Enron of the airwaves. Another $7.8 million deficit is forecast.

For an organisation so exquisitely attuned to the structural failings of capitalism, it has a surprisingly rudimentary grasp of arithmetic. The unions want a pause in redundancies. Labour wants a cross-party intervention. Its ideological support animal is in distress.

Yet amid the operatic lamentations about how much money RNZ needs, remarkably little consideration has been given to what RNZ might do differently to make New Zealanders actually want to listen to it.

Kohimarama housewives are authorities on all matters pertaining to the wireless. No spring clean is complete without some background chatter and a side of classical music. Yet listening to RNZ increasingly feels like intercepting the internal communications of a university sociology department. There is a pervasive sense that somewhere, someone is being oppressed, someone else is insufficiently cognisant of it, and someone with a postgraduate qualification is about to make the next twenty minutes of your life considerably less enjoyable.

The possibility that ordinary New Zealanders might be running businesses, raising families and forming perfectly sensible opinions without the assistance of a publicly funded facilitator seems to cause measurable editorial discomfort. One longs for an interview with a successful entrepreneur who isn’t required to apologise for the economic system that facilitated their success. Or an agricultural story in which the farmer isn’t introduced as an environmental complication. Or a discussion about reducing government expenditure without the accompanying acoustic atmosphere of a state funeral.

Meanwhile, over at Newstalk ZB, something quite extraordinary is happening.

People are voluntarily listening.

In the May 2026 commercial radio survey, Newstalk ZB topped the national rankings with 657,400 weekly listeners and a 14.4 per cent share of commercial radio listening. Mike Hosking and Heather du Plessis-Allan have managed to make current affairs commercially compelling without an annual fiscal transfusion from the taxpayer. Neither is ideologically neutral, nor do they pretend to be. But they understand that broadcasting is a conversation with the public, not a disciplinary procedure.

Heather, in particular, possesses that increasingly rare broadcasting attribute: the ability to conduct an interview without making it about her own moral credentials. She has a glorious intolerance of the semantic blancmange in which politicians traditionally encase their non-answers and can extract more information from a reluctant Cabinet Minister in four minutes than a select committee can in an entire parliamentary term.

Now, before somebody accuses me of wanting to replace the National Programme with six uninterrupted hours of Mike Hosking discussing European automotive engineering, I believe there is a legitimate role for public broadcasting.

Emergency communications, investigative journalism, regional reporting, classical music, serious international coverage and intelligent long-form interviews all have considerable public value. RNZ reports substantial digital reach, growth in radio listening and strong public support for public media. There are also some excellent journalists at RNZ. Indeed, watching its own reporters interrogate management over this financial debacle has been one of the more encouraging aspects of the entire affair.

But public broadcasting is a function, not a theology. Being boring is not a public service. Nor is being ideologically agreeable to one’s colleagues a professional qualification.

Were I on the RNZ Board, I might propose some genuinely radical initiatives:

– Recruit people with a diversity of intellectual perspectives rather than a diversity of people with identical intellectual perspectives.

– Treat commercial success as a subject of legitimate interest rather than the preliminary evidence in a criminal investigation.

– Distinguish between journalism and activism. I don’t need a side of outrage, masquerading as objectivity, with my Vogel’s.

– Commission programmes on the basis of what New Zealanders might find interesting rather than what a the Grey Lynn lentil protection society thinks New Zealanders ought to find morally improving.

– Introduce the revolutionary concept that the audience might occasionally know something the broadcaster doesn’t.

Above all, RNZ needs to reacquaint itself with the notion that its audience is its raison d’être, not an intellectually underdeveloped demographic in need of remediation. The great irony is that RNZ has spent years interrogating the sustainability of other people’s economic models while apparently neglecting to develop one of its own. It has confused public funding with public endorsement, editorial consensus with intellectual rigour, and a captive taxpayer with a captive audience.

Unfortunately, while New Zealanders cannot turn off the funding, they can turn off the radio.