By Roger Childs
In the midst of life we are in death. 1 Thessalonians 4;16
Death and taxes
“Our new Constitution is now established, and has an appearance that promises permanency; but in this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes.” –Benjamin Franklin 1789
Pam and I have lost seven very good friends this year including two in consecutive days in July. One of the seven chose to die with dignity once he knew he qualified. His right lung had disintegrated and it was only a matter of time before the left lung followed suit. I was fortunate to be able to visit Ross before he died, and arrived in Wellington Hospital at the same time as another friend. We had a great three-way chat on the Friday and Ross died with dignity the following Tuesday.
There was a time when this end of life choice was illegal and people with zero chance of recovery had to put themselves through excruciating pain waiting to die. Sadly the need to qualify for this option is limited and the Catholic Church and the Hospice movement, with one notable exception, are opposed and subscribe to the highly debatable belief ‘Where’s there’s life there’s hope’.
The last orange
Back in 1980 my mother lay in Napier Hospital waiting to die, She couldn’t talk; didn’t recognise anyone; was incontinent and uncomfortable, and didn’t eat, but the law in those days did not allow her to die with dignity.
My devoted father lived 300 metres away and visited her regularly twice every day. He squeezed juice from the oranges on a productive tree in the back garden and always took her a drink which she did sip. Extraordinarily but highly appropriately, on the day he squeezed the last orange she drank the juice and died peacefully.
Les animaux des compagnies

This is the delightful French term for pets. We currently have a 20 year cat who is a great survivor. She is struggling at times with her walking and is gradually losing control of her bowels. Nevertheless she eats well and enjoys walking around the outside of the house, Often we will let her out the front door and she will use the nearby garden before heading round the villa and coming in her cat door into the conservatory.
We are devoted to her and would like her to live forever. She enjoys our company and does not give the impression that she wants to give her life away. It is a dilemma but when the time comes there are no legal limits. We can make the choice of what we do on the cat’s behalf. Currently we are manging the situation and Ginge seems to be enjoying life, Long may it continue!
Helping those who want to pass on
(This material is drawn from the End-Of-Life Choice Society of New Zealand September Newsletter)
The Society feels that the public is better educated on the issues associated with Dying with Dignity than five years ago. Doulas are helping people nearing their end. They can help with getting documentation in order, communicating between health care services, explaining death and dying to children and other family, providing comforting cares to the dying person and sitting with a dying person to give family a break or to ensure the person does not die alone.
There are two legal options for people who don’t qualify under New Zealand laws:
- Voluntarily Stop Eating and Drinking. This is what Dr David Hadorn chose. (See WW assisted dying is being able to make the best choice .Sunday 19 April 2026)
- Going to Switzerland and using one of their Voluntary Assisted Death Centres. (Obviously the cost is considerable with this option.)
No, this is not Canada!
The story is about US Airforce veteran Kirstin Logan going to Canada to get affordable health care and being told about assisted dying before getting an oncologist’s appointment. The government north of the border definitely has its priorities round the wrong way. (See this post from the past week)
In New Zealand the government needs to broaden the eligibility rules for dying with dignity, but those in authority will never pressurize people to take advantage of assisted dying. The Health authorities and doctors are happy to give advice, but as regards assisted dying there are many groups who are strongly opposed to “dying with dignity”. If immigrants or anyone wants information on the subject it would be best to approach the End of Life Choice Society of New Zealand.

Under the End of Life Choice Act 2019, practitioners must actively verify both competence and freedom from coercion through strict legal and clinical checks throughout the entire process.
- The Four Legal Criteria. Under Section 6 of the Act, a person is only competent if they can demonstrate they are able to understand, retain, and use or weigh information about assisted dying, and communicate their decision in some way. [1, 2]
- Dual Medical Assessments. Both the attending doctor and an independent doctor must separately assess and confirm the patient’s competence. [1, 2]
- Mandatory Psychiatric Evaluation. If either doctor has any doubt about the patient’s competence, a psychiatrist must conduct a third, formal assessment. If the psychiatrist cannot confirm competence, the process stops. [1, 2]
- Ongoing Verification. Competence is not a one-time check. The patient must remain competent at every stage—including right up to the moment the medication is administered. Because of this, advance directives cannot be used.
- Eligibility Requirements: Patients must be aged 18 or older, be a New Zealand citizen or permanent resident, have a terminal illness expected to end their life within 6 months, experience irreversible physical decline and unbearable suffering, and possess the competence to make an informed choice. Eligibility cannot be based solely on mental illness, disability, dementia, or advanced age. [1, 2, 3, 4]
- Independent Assessments: Both an attending practitioner and an independent doctor must evaluate and agree on the patient’s eligibility. A psychiatrist must evaluate the patient if competence is in doubt. [1, 2, 3]
- Voluntary Consent: The process must be patient-initiated; doctors cannot suggest assisted dying. Competence is required throughout, meaning advance directives or welfare guardians cannot request it. Patients can withdraw at any time. [1, 2, 3]
- Practitioner Protections: Health practitioners maintain the right to conscientious objection. [1, 2]
- Independent Oversight: The Registrar (assisted dying) and the End of Life Review Committee monitor and audit cases to ensure full compliance with the Act. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Taxes and death
For all of us taxes and levies of various sorts are a reality and we also face the certainty that the “grim reaper” will one day seek us out. In the meantime we need to make the best of our on-going time left.
